Haplogroup J and the Jewish Cohen Modal Haplotype
By
Ishaq Al-Sulaimani
DNA evidence does not support the
claim that the Jewish people living
in Israel are descendants of the
ancient Israelites. On the contrary
DNA evidence proves that the vast
majority of Jewish people around the
world are not Israelite by patrilineal
descent meaning of the seed of
Abraham,Isaac and Jacob.
Judaism is a religion comprised
of numerous and various peoples
of all races and ethnicities. Israelites
are the descendants of Abraham,Isaac
and Jacob. Israelites are scattered
around the world and can be found
practicing every religion. DNA testing
has proven that Judaism is a religion
as the Jewish people have tested
positive for at least 8 distinct and
unrelated lineages.
J1 is the only Semitic Haplogroup
recognized by geneticists. It appears
heavily in Ethiopia,Yemen and Arabia.
It is also common amongst Bedouins.
STR markers are used to specify
lineages within a specific haplogroup.
The Kohenim which are found within
the Buba clan of the Lemba tribe of South
Africa, the descendants of Muhammad
(Ishmael) and the Solomonic Amhara
of Ethiopia are all defined by specific
STR Markers within the J1 Haplogroup.
Only 4% of Jewish people around the
world claim to be Kohen. DNA testing
eliminated more than half of those
claims. Meaning that less than 2%
of Jewish people are actually of
authentic Kohen descent.
Approximately 13% of
the Jewish people have the
J1 haplogroup. This means
that almost 90% of the Jewish
people are not Semitic or
Israelite for that matter.
The Israelite Amhara of
Ethiopia have 10 times the
amount of J1 than all of
the Jewish people combined.
The Buba clan has a higher
ratio of Kohenim in comparison
to any Jewish community.
Only the ancient Kurdish Jews
have a ratio of Kohenim comparable
to that of the Buba(Lemba).
Note: J2 is not Semitic but
Phoenician, which was a
mixture of Semitic and Hamitic.
Some Israelite STR markers
were identified in J2 such as
a limited amount of Kohenim.
However J2 is not Semitic
and should not be confused
or combined with J1. J2
is non-existent in Ethiopia.
Matrilineal Judaism which
considers paternity irrelevant
to Jewish status could not
possibly inherit that which was
promised to the seed of Abraham,
Isaac and Jacob.
Below is a DNA Site presented
by an educated Jewish woman
which clearly demonstrates
the fact that the vast majority
of Jewish people are not J1.
Page 4- J1 constitutes 14.6%
of Ashkenazi results and 11.9%
of Sephardic results
thank you again. Yah bless!!!
http://www.jogg.info/11/coffman.htm
It’s fun to find that my haplogroup is J1C from my all-Irish mother. Validates the migration pattern of some Jews in ancient times.
Mariel
You’re referring to MtDNA
and not Y DNA
BTW I belong to Mt DNA J1c too
it’s a European sublcade
It’s not Middle Eastern.
Not really, Romans brought Saracen archers to Britain. Your looking at a small segment below J1-YSC234 in L147 which modern Jews carry. British Isle J1, is well known in itself. Have you tested your SNP’s? Or STR’s for CMHe?
From your mother would be mtdna, this article is referencing Ydna. Mtdna haplogroup J isn’t semetic.
How about Maltese people? They have the highest percent of J2 markers found around the world. Also, Maltese like Hebrew is deemed semetic and clearly came from israel.
Recap – Maltese are the closest things in the world to modern day Phoenicians which came from Israel and is known to be semetic.
Side note: Malta is know to have the second oldest jewish community outside of Israel!
Please explain.
Thank you.
Ingush people have 88% J2 ! They have highest J2 in the World. Tehy live between Black sea and Caspian sea.
Hi Ponto,
You’re response is very aggressive is this because you’re ashamed of the 5% found in your own testing? I know you’re Maltese and have viewed your DNA report. Don’t be ashamed my friend for we are all children of God:)
It is not our blood that defines us it’s how we treat others.
yes i am jm 172 what does that mean that 88.8 percent are j2??? is that good thing???
Phoenicians are not found in Israel Phoenicians are found in Lebanon.
Malta is as ancient Phoenician word for refuge and Malta used to be colonised by the Phoenicians.
Just to recap Maltese people have Phoenician DNA Phoenicians are from Lebanon making them lebanese making the Maltese lebanese not Israelite.
Maltese language is an Arabic dialect. it’s tunisian but with italian vocabulary instead of arabic. but the structure and grammar is like tunisian in general. the explanation is that malta was for a long time under islamic rule but they did not convert. So after being ruled by christians they forgot to use arabic vocabulary they borrow their vocabulary from latin bible but the structure of their language remains semitic( tunisian arabic). phenicians were their before islam so having J2 in malta is quite easy to understand
I don’t know where you get you information about Maltese genetics, Jeff, but it is wrong. J2 is 21%, other J mostly J1 is 8%. Anyway all that haplogroup stuff is antique, autosomal dna testing is the in thing now. European Jews are mostly European, something like 60%, the rest is not really from the Middle East, it is Anatolian and from the Caucasus.
I suggest you do some reading before making silly statements.
Ponto
European Jews are mostly European, something like 60% ?? Are you nutt?? LOL
the facts are:
1. the Haplogroup of Abraham’s sons: J1c3d (+L147)..
2. (Autosomal DNA test) or (maternal test) wouldn’t help. and has nothing to do with facts..
3. You’re out of luck to be a real Jew. and not even close.. (I mean an ancestor )
4. Europeans are a Jews servants.. this is what people know..
5. I’m really sorry to say that….. but it’s the truth..
Ponto’s comment is likely in the ballpark.
Ashkenazi Jews have likely between 55% and 65% European ancestry on average, depending on what study you reference.
Autosomally Ashkenazi Jews are very much like Greek admixed South /Central Italians/Sicilians/Peloponnese Greeks and Greeks from Crete.
The “Middle Eastern” component of Ashkenazi Jews has been show by several studies to be closely related to Kurds, Turks, Armenians and Iranians.
I would call, it West Asian and not “Middle Eastern” at all.
Do some research Sean before insulting a guy that has his facts correct….
Guys,
Lets not get twisted by the findings of the DNA from the present day Jewish populations. Anyone could become a jew but not everyone is an actual descendant of the Children of Israel. The Jewish populations today are a mixture of many different people and therefore you will find large amounts of foreign DNA within their lineage. The evidence is becoming much more clear as time unfolds. The only DNA haplogroup you will find within all the ancient tribes of Hebrews who are not necessarily Jewish is haplogroup E. The haplogroup J isnt of middle eastern or African origin it never was and no DNA scientist will ever claim this. J originated from the caucausus and above and was introduced into the area after. Anyway common sense will tell you that the Hebrews were sent into exile and left the area so tracking the sampling the DNA of grops of people in the area now will be of no factual use because the people who are there now only represent the people who came into the area after we had left.
How many different people came into the area after we had left and gone into exile? There were Turkic, Roman, Greek and we know that there are many Greeks who are haplo group J, and many others and they would have been there after the exile. And many of these groups converted to Judaism but they couldn’t change their DNA.
The missinformation and great hatred of the real Hebrew people have fueled the blindness of the rest of the world to see the obvious truth that the real hebrews have been living among them for years as so called black people and they have been told that jews are white therefore we cannot possibly be Jews. I agree with them I am not a jew but Hebrew a descendent of the Children of Israel which something completely different. Yes there are some jews who do have the DNA of the Chidlren of Israel but the majority of the jews today are not the descendants of Bani Israel. The Children of Israel are one people genetically therefore they must have the same genetic material and code simple. We are not like Islam or another religion where people can just join no; we are a race of people so inclusion is simply a matter of genetics. It is the modern day Jewish religion that has declared that you can convert to become a jew. And, again I agree you can convert tobecome a jew but you must be born a child of Israel in order to become a child of Israel. The curses travel in your blood and many of the jewish people today do not look like they suffered any of the curses whatsoever and in fact they have been doing quite well in fact. So this for me is a simple evidence that they are not the children of Israel. But, there are some which are Children of israel.
All of the smoke and nonse we are seeing today is the jewish zionist lobby and the American right-wing Christians trying to defend their positions because it weakens their positions considerably. The Zionist loses his claim to the holy land and Right wing American Christian has to admit that they have had a hand in oppressing God’s people. Also when they believed we were hametic it was easier to treat us badly because we deserved it due the rubbish we are the cursed descendants of Ham. But, it very funny why we have the same DNA as the Hebrews and not the Hametic people. And, now I have even seen people trying to say that E1b1a is hametic line. This is where they fall into a real big problem if E1b1a is hametic and E1b1b is Hebrew how the hell are they going to say J1 is Hebrew, it is totally a different haplogroup. E1b1a and E1b1b are seperated by a sub-sub clade which means they are the same people seperated by distance in time or who split into two groups. This we know to be true because our ancestors said we did. So, if E1b1a isn’t Hebrew J1 is from a different planet. E is the only Hebrew haplogroup they know it we know it now and the migration routes fit the stories of the exile perfectly.
I’ll let the disbelievers argue because God said simply that he will stretch out his hand a second time and gather us back again but he also said that he would make us for get our heritageprior to this as a punishment. No one else falls into this description except those who were E1b1a and especially those taken during slavery to the Caribbean and Americas.
So, I not too bothered by their rantings as the DNA speaks for itself and God is speaking to us through the results of the DNA. This is the in gathering of the Israel and Judah and I am not surprised that people who were fed a lie including some Hebrews themselves find it difficult to believe we are indeed Hebrews. Even I was told as a child but we didn’t take it seriously we were brain washed too and thought it was a lie. Now, I got myself tested and I was E1b1a and have been studying our history for the past two years and everything point to the same results the history, scripture and now DNA; Hebrew.
You say that no genetics Scientist will ever say that The haplogroup J isnt of middle eastern or African origin it never was and no DNA scientist will ever claim this. J originated from the Caucasus and above and was introduced into the area after.
Well Here is J1c Ancestral migration path, so I don’t know how you come to your conclusions.
Haplogroup J1, M267 (Subclade J1c, L136)
M168, Time of Emergence: Roughly 50,000 years ago
Place of Origin: Africa
lineage probably lived in northeast Africa in
the region of the Rift Valley, perhaps in present-day Ethiopia , Kenya, or Tanzania, some 31,000 to
79,000 years ago. Scientists put the most likely date for when he lived at around 50,000 years ago.
His descendants became the only lineage to survive outside of Africa, making him the common ancestor of every non-African man living today.
M89: Moving Through the Middle East,
Time of Emergence: 45,000 years ago
Place: Northern Africa or the Middle East
The man who gave rise to M89, a marker found in
90 to 95 percent of all non-Africans. This man was born around 45,000 years ago in northern Africa or the Middle East.
M304; Time of Emergence:15,000 to 10,000 years ago
Place of origin: Fertile Crescent.
The patriarch of M304 was a descendant of the M89 Middle Eastern clan. He was born between
15,000 to 10,000 years ago in the Fertile Crescent, a region that extends from the Mediterranean
Sea to the Persian Gulf where the Euphrates and Tigris rivers form an extremely rich floodplain.
Today the region includes all or parts of Israel, the West Bank, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, and Iraq.
The M304 marker appears at its highest frequencies in the Middle East, North Africa, and Ethiopia. In Europe, it is seen only in the Mediterranean region.
An important subgroup of this group includes the descendants of another man from the M89 Middle
Eastern clan born in the Fertile Crescent at about the same time, carrying the marker M172.
The early farming successes of these lineages spawned population booms and encouraged
migration throughout much of the Mediterranean world. In fact, both haplogroup M304 and its
subgroup M172 are found at a combined frequency of around 30 percent amongst Jewish individuals.
M267; Time of Emergence: About 10,000 years ago
Place of origin: Fertile Crescent
The M267 haplogroup arose in the southern Fertile Crescent, perhaps in what is now Iraq, about
10,000 years ago. In this post-Ice Age era the region had a very fertile climate, which helped to feed
the growth of early agriculture and, with it, the foundations of settled human communities.
The first man to exhibit the M267 marker was probably an early agriculturalist. During successive
generations, his descendents would carry the lineage through much of the Middle East, the Arabian
Peninsula, and North Africa.
The M267 lineage was widely dispersed by two major waves of migration. The first occurred some
10,000 years ago during the region’s Neolithic period. The homesteading farmers of this era spread
out from the Fertile Crescent into the welcoming lands of Europe, Ethiopia, and even farther afield.
More recently, during the golden age of Islamic expansion, some descendents of the original M267
spread to North Africa and to Europe’s Iberian Peninsula. The Moors, North African peoples of
Berber and Arab origins, carried both their faith and their culture on conquests of the Iberian
Peninsula, northwest Africa, and beyond. Their genetic impact on Spain, however, was relatively
small.
Modern members of this haplogroup once again live in their highest concentrations near its ancestral
birthplace in the Middle East, as well as in Arabia, North Africa, and Ethiopia. M267 is also seen in
Mediterranean Europe, though at much lower frequencies.
The haplogroup also carries a strong cultural connection—many of its members with European
ancestry are Jewish. More than half of all J1, M267 (Subclade J1c, L136) samples in the
Genographic database are Ashkenazi Jews, revealing a genetic connection to the Middle Eastern homeland of Judaism. So how is it you can say that no genetic scientist will never say that . This is from the leading Genographic program in the world.
Will meet on the battle field.
Golan israeli Hebrew jew decendant of king david lineage and worshipper of the one true g… of abraham isaac and Jacob.
A true zionist.
http://www.facebook.com/e1b1ahaplogroupnation
I know for a fact that Mohammad (pbuh) are from E1b1b1 haplogroup . He is not originally from Abrab tribes. His ancestory is from Ibrahim and Ishmail not from Arab tribes which are J haplogroup. I am sure that all isrealites are from E1b1b1 haplogroup. I don’t understand why Jewish people spreading this lie. Are they consider them whites.
not true man its j for sure
I know later results will show is not J .. but E
The Issue with this report is that in order to understand a ethnic people you look at the total amount of haplotype breakdowns and compare that with other populations…Most semetic ethnic groups have a similar breakdown,,,a certain amount of J1, J2, e1b…Even arab groups carry haplogroups R1b, R1a, Q, G ,etc…The important note to comparing the ethnic groups is to see how much of each haplotype is found and at what rate…All jewish groups have similar breakdowns of haplotypes with ashkenazim having more r1a, sephardics having more r1b,,, etc…both having similar frequencies of J1,j2,e1b…and also comparing jewish groups to middle eastern non jewish groups you see the same thing…similar breakdowns of J and E haplogroups,, with small amounts of Q,R,G ,etc as well…..